« Which prospect pitcher is more valuable?
POLL:Which of these pitching staffs would you choose? »

Would this be a fair trade to offer?

Sixteen and Oh asked:


I am thinking about offering JJ Hardy and Matt Holliday for Ichiro Suzuki and Michael Young. Here is my team.
C Miguel Olive
1B Lance Berkman
2B Orlando Hudson
3B Miguel Cabrera
SS Jason Bartlett
OF Magglio Ordonez
OF Matt Holliday
OF Corey Hart
UTIL Ryan Braun
BN Luis Gonzalez
BN Alex Gordon
BN Shannon Stewart
BN JJ Hardy
SP CC Sabathia
SP Brandon Webb
RP Al Reyes
RP Jeremy Accardo
P Aaron Harang
P John Maine
P James Shields
BN Tim Lincecum
DL Huston Street

Im good in all offensive categories except SB, which Im 10 out of 12 at. Im mediocre at W and S, but belowe average at ERA and WHIP. Im fine with Ks though. Advice is welcomed. I’m in 5 out of a 12 team roto league default settings. Anywhere from 2nd to 7th is wide open.

Tim Lincecum

This entry was posted on Saturday, April 25th, 2009 at 10:45 pm and is filed under Tim Lincecum. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

7 Responses to “Would this be a fair trade to offer?”

  1. Full Tilt Bonus Code

    it would be a fair offer, but if you get counter offered don’t worry. work with the other guy but don’t give up to much. also check your wavier wire. i know you said you are in a 12 team league but i’m sure there are some talented players on the waiver wire and free agent pools

  2. Tim Lincecum

    Try and offer it! I would probably accept if i was the other guy! But it all depends on my team

  3. CA Vehichle Registration

    This is a pretty even trade. Holiday and Hardy will definetely get you more homers, but Ichiro and Young will get you more steals, which is what you need. Ichiro is also very consistent and will always have a high average. What you could do is try to trade Holiday for Ichiro and then try Hardy for another SS with more steals.

  4. Trade Barry Zito

    This trade looks pretty good. It would help to see his roster too, to determine if he needs power. Good Luck.

  5. Razz Strategy

    fair deal

  6. Tim Lincecum

    it is a good trade but I would take tim lincecum of the bench. HE RULES!

  7. Cereus Rakeback

    Even enough trade, how does his roster look???

Leave a Reply